[{"id": 16524377, "authorName": "kbw123", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/kbw123/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "Looks like a nice bike. Can we get a video of it starting and running? Thanks.", "likes": 2, "timestamp": 1736200525, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16524403, "authorName": "bmwcca1", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/bmwcca1/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "Brings back fond memories! \r\n\r\nPeople will be asking, so: \r\nYou bought this bike six-months ago from a dealer in Florida who had only owned it a month, shipped it 2/3 of the way across the country, and now you're selling it after putting possibly ten-miles on it? \r\n\r\nHaving owned a new R50/5 from new back in 1971 and traveling through Colorado with it, even solo, I can tell you why I sold mine and now have R60/5s. But lets hear your story. My condolences if you've had a health issue that prohibits you from motorcycling. All the best.", "likes": 5, "timestamp": 1736201038, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16524518, "authorName": "bobofohio", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/bobofohio/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "The crack in the lower triple clamp shown in picture 15 should be of concern. The bolt was either over-tightened at one point, or the wrong bolt was put in. While it is possible to repair the part, it should be replaced due to strength issues. The lower clamp is what holds the fork vertically. The top clamp just keeps it in alignment. My credentials are \"I machine aluminum forgings and castings for a living\".\r\n\r\n@originalbob - what do you think? Have you seen and repaired this damage before?", "likes": 3, "timestamp": 1736202273, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16524638, "authorName": "originalbob", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/originalbob/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "@bobofohio - I had not taken the time to closely look at this bike as it held no interest for me for myriad reasons. I did look at image 15 as I got an alert to your comment. MNSHO after 45 plus years engaged with BMWs on many levels is that the part should be replaced. And one should look closer to see if there are any other issues related to this very rare failure.\r\n\r\nWhile I'm sure someone of your expertise could fix it, that repair would likely show up even with lots of finishing effort to hide such work. \r\n\r\nThat may or may not be a deal breaker for the next owner as there are numerous other things about this bike that stand out, and not for positive reasons in my mind; mostly that it is far from original in so many ways.\r\n\r\nI hope that helps all who may be looking at this machine to purchase.", "likes": 1, "timestamp": 1736203777, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16525841, "authorName": "FanofClassic_BMW (The Seller)", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/fanofclassic_bmw/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736221023, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16525849, "authorName": "FanofClassic_BMW (The Seller)", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/fanofclassic_bmw/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "@kbw123 Sorry it took so long to post this. Very busy day.", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736221199, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16525850, "authorName": "FanofClassic_BMW (The Seller)", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/fanofclassic_bmw/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "@bmwcca1 Yes, the bike was purchased in July. Years ago I had a 72 R50/5 but had to let it go for financial reasons. It was a difficult thing to do at the time. This was bought with the intention of filling that void but it's just not the same as my old toaster tank /5. So I've decided to put this up for auction and hopefully find the toaster tank /5 that matches closer to my old steed.", "likes": 2, "timestamp": 1736221273, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16525921, "authorName": "FanofClassic_BMW (The Seller)", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/fanofclassic_bmw/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "@bobofohio Obviously I'm not trying to hide things from the potential buyer or I would have excluded this photo from the auction - like the last seller did. Thanks for pointing it out. Your keen eye is appreciated by the bidders, I'm sure. No question which team you and @originalbob are rooting for here. Luckily, there is a /5 lower triple tree on Ebay for sale right now. Btw, it is a 45yo bike and I'm not claiming it's Smithsonian quality.", "likes": 5, "timestamp": 1736222863, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16526777, "authorName": "Ken_Buchanan", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/ken_buchanan/", "bidAmount": 100, "content": "$100 bid placed by Ken_Buchanan", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736260600, "type": "bat-bid"}, {"id": 16526803, "authorName": "Catana246", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/catana246/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "@seller, perhaps you might consider buying the lower triple clamp to include with your bike. You know, for your conscience and all\u2026", "likes": 2, "timestamp": 1736261061, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16526862, "authorName": "bobofohio", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/bobofohio/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "@FanofClassic_BMW - I think this is a nice bike and agree with @Catana246 in his suggestion that you buy the Ebay part - not necessarily for your conscience, but just to get the most money. I have no agenda in trying to influence auctions, and am impressed that you did include the picture, as opposed to the guy you bought it from. I have a lot of BMW's and really like the /5's and /6's without the toaster tanks. If you look at my bid history, you will see I bid on one not long ago. If I weren't so flush with bikes, I'd have bought that one.\r\n\r\nGood luck, you seem like a good guy and I hope you get your money back on this, and find the one you want as well.\r\n\r\nBob H", "likes": 1, "timestamp": 1736261786, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16527096, "authorName": "nigel9", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/nigel9/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "@bobofohio and @originalbob Is there not a crack on the other side too? Images 15 and 16?", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736263818, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16527149, "authorName": "Kasindy", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/kasindy/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "A lot has to happen before you can REPLACE that part. It's about a four or five hour job if you have the tools and skills. If you drop one ball bearing on the floor figure another hour. The seller is disenchanted with his purchase and wishes it would go away. Great opportunity for someone who doesn't have to ship.", "likes": 2, "timestamp": 1736264536, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16527852, "authorName": "shooker", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/shooker/", "bidAmount": 250, "content": "$250 bid placed by shooker", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736270488, "type": "bat-bid"}, {"id": 16530049, "authorName": "fjk43", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/fjk43/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "First looked at the comment about the slight crack, [15] hopefully they are not referring to the 2 vertical it must be the horizontal. could be welded.", "likes": 1, "timestamp": 1736277768, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16531477, "authorName": "landog", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/landog/", "bidAmount": 350, "content": "$350 bid placed by landog", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736282389, "type": "bat-bid"}, {"id": 16532957, "authorName": "Kasindy", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/kasindy/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "@fjk that's the dream. I've seen these pinch bolts tightened to insane amounts, but never seen one pulled through the threads like this appears. My guess is you would have to take this part down to the welding shop and completely filled in. Then drill and tap a new bolt hole. I'd go with Ebay. That part is probably common to all /5's.", "likes": 3, "timestamp": 1736291223, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16533380, "authorName": "james.strang.az", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/james.strang.az/", "bidAmount": 1000, "content": "$1,000 bid placed by james.strang.az", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736295323, "type": "bat-bid"}, {"id": 16536480, "authorName": "Johnny_Haywire", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/johnny_haywire/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "Wait, you guys don't tighten until you hear the \"click\" and then back off a quarter turn? (kidding...)\r\nI'd just take it as an opportunity to do the steering head bearings and fork seals. It's not that bad of a job as long as you document/mark/photograph the cable and wiring routing before disassembly. These things happen, people overtighten things. Plus, if you're going to install lower/Euro bars, that's a quarter of the disassembly right there. \r\nGLWTA @seller, it's a nice bike. If I didn't have the same exact one, I'd be interested.", "likes": 6, "timestamp": 1736359191, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16542382, "authorName": "bobofohio", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/bobofohio/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "Buying the replacement part on ebay for $80 is a no brainer. While it might be \"possible\" to fix the existing part, it would only make sense to do so if it were absolutely unreplaceable.", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736435843, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16542540, "authorName": "ThePoz1951", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/thepoz1951/", "bidAmount": 1100, "content": "$1,100 bid placed by ThePoz1951", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736437469, "type": "bat-bid"}, {"id": 16542883, "authorName": "FanofClassic_BMW (The Seller)", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/fanofclassic_bmw/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "@Catana246 and @bobofohio, I would consider getting the part but according to the FAQs, I cannot ship the part with the bike if it cannot fit inside it. \r\n\"Any parts that cannot be stored safely inside the vehicle must be shipped separately. Any items inside the vehicle (spare parts, personal belongings, etc) are not insured and will not be considered in cases of damage.\" \r\nThe part has free shipping so why should I purchase it, have it shipped to me and then risk it being damaged in shipping it again? ...along with the extra cost. Help me understand your logic.", "likes": 2, "timestamp": 1736440195, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16543527, "authorName": "bobofohio", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/bobofohio/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "@FanofClassic_BMW copying @Catana246 - my point about acquiring the part and including it with the sale is to assure the buyer they will get the part. I see only one on ebay, and it might not be there after the sale. If I were bidding on this bike, I'd bid a lot more knowing the part was included. It's the only thing on this otherwise really nice bike that would hold ME back. That's my logic.\r\n\r\nWRT to Haul Bikes (the service I always use) not taking extra parts, I'm sure they wouldn't have a problem with the triple clamp heavily zip tied to the frame. They just don't want to be accountable for loose items. For the record, they'll take a bike from just about anywhere to anywhere for $500-$700, at least from my experience with them, which is a lot.\r\n\r\nBob", "likes": 1, "timestamp": 1736444714, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16543751, "authorName": "Catana246", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/catana246/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "@seller, I am sorry for the snarky tone of my first comment. In my world, if trying to sell a bike/boat/car that needs an essential part to be whole, the goodwill of including such part(s) will often be reflected in the sale price. I am not going to tell you how to wrap in canvas or cardboard the triple clamp and securely attach it to the rack behind the saddle so the new owner has what he or she needs to make your bike safe & enjoyable. \r\nGood luck on your toaster quest!", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736446193, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16546536, "authorName": "Kasindy", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/kasindy/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "Using my demented logic, fix the bike before you put it on an open forum type auction. That way you might get more for it and not have to put up with all this crap. But then I have time to trifle with such repairs. There is nothing on this basic transportation German motorcycle that can't be fixed.", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736456558, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16549779, "authorName": "StaffordRestorations", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/staffordrestorations/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "@bobofohio many of the triple clamps for the /5 are listed on eBay. Some with forks, some without. There are by no means a shortage of them and most /5 builders have a few in stock. My logic is, you know what the bike needs and bid according.\r\nAnd it\u2019s a EZ swap for a /5 guy. No need to even disconnect all the cables. Tie the bars and headlight to the overhead and drop the forks. I personally would have switched it out before listening, that way the guys with all thumbs might be willing to bid.\r\nBut the guys with fingers get a deal this way. \ud83d\ude09", "likes": 5, "timestamp": 1736482633, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16549999, "authorName": "Johnny_Haywire", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/johnny_haywire/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "The vibe I'm getting here is that the seller found out about that crack after the auction went live and not beforehand. I actually went and checked my R50/5 to make sure it wasn't showing any signs of overtightening there. It's not an area I look at regularly, since my eye is always drawn to the heads and exhaust and just to marvel at how gorgeous the bike is as a whole.\r\nLike @StaffordRestorations mentioned, this is not a hard part to source or replace. I'd rather do this than a clutch any day.", "likes": 2, "timestamp": 1736490702, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16551547, "authorName": "Ken_Buchanan", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/ken_buchanan/", "bidAmount": 1200, "content": "$1,200 bid placed by Ken_Buchanan", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736527515, "type": "bat-bid"}, {"id": 16553096, "authorName": "FanofClassic_BMW (The Seller)", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/fanofclassic_bmw/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "Good day everyone! The auction is creeping closer to its close. For those interested in this beautiful bike, and those that had valid concerns for the crack in the lower triple tree, I have purchased the part for replacement. I will securely fasten it to the bike for shipment. Thank you all for your expert opinions and insight. This is my first auction as a seller and I am learning as I go. I appreciate the constructive information you have provided. Cheers", "likes": 11, "timestamp": 1736534523, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16553287, "authorName": "sgmfrpsrgthoa", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/sgmfrpsrgthoa/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "Great bikes for sure! If you don't mind going slow you can do it with style with this. Sorry, guess I was born to be a smart ass. I meant the great bike part. Good luck to all. Figure out how to get in touch with me if you needs parts or projects.", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736535093, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16553933, "authorName": "Kasindy", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/kasindy/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "@FanofClassic BMW That was awesome. Expect positive results.", "likes": 1, "timestamp": 1736536855, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16564686, "authorName": "Ant5842", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/ant5842/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "These bikes can be modded to achieve a greater displacement if so desired, and pretty easily too. \r\n\r\nNice move by the seller to include the replacement fork clamp. Shows good character. \r\n\r\nGood luck to all involved!", "likes": 1, "timestamp": 1736654558, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16566690, "authorName": "Gramatan", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/gramatan/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "Lovely R50/5 especially with the tall tank, mellow, reliable but steep-ish uphill \r\nperformance might not be outstanding. \r\n\r\nCould you show provide pictures of tool kit/pump/manual if extant. Also tools in and out please.", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736705583, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16567762, "authorName": "FanofClassic_BMW (The Seller)", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/fanofclassic_bmw/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "@Gramatan, there was no manual or tool kit included with the bike when purchased last. There is a pump. I am working to get the pic uploaded to the site. Please stand by.", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736709815, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16569068, "authorName": "james.strang.az", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/james.strang.az/", "bidAmount": 1500, "content": "$1,500 bid placed by james.strang.az", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736726179, "type": "bat-bid"}, {"id": 16569809, "authorName": "FanofClassic_BMW (The Seller)", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/fanofclassic_bmw/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "@Gramtan, I did find a /5 toolkit in my shed. It looks like there may be some items missing but for the most part it is almost complete. Still no manual though.", "likes": 1, "timestamp": 1736740909, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16569812, "authorName": "FanofClassic_BMW (The Seller)", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/fanofclassic_bmw/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "@Gramatan, misspelled your handle. See comment and pics below.", "likes": 2, "timestamp": 1736741088, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16571017, "authorName": "thinkfuture", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/thinkfuture/", "bidAmount": 2000, "content": "$2,000 bid placed by thinkfuture", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736783087, "type": "bat-bid"}, {"id": 16571444, "authorName": "FanofClassic_BMW (The Seller)", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/fanofclassic_bmw/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "Photo of the pump", "likes": 1, "timestamp": 1736786916, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16572067, "authorName": "colorado56", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/colorado56/", "bidAmount": 2500, "content": "$2,500 bid placed by colorado56", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736791688, "type": "bat-bid"}, {"id": 16573672, "authorName": "treybiensmith", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/treybiensmith/", "bidAmount": 2700, "content": "$2,700 bid placed by treybiensmith", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736797086, "type": "bat-bid"}, {"id": 16574861, "authorName": "FanofClassic_BMW (The Seller)", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/fanofclassic_bmw/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "Less than an hour left on this auction. Don't let this beautiful bike slip away from you. Good luck to all bidders!", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736801024, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16574935, "authorName": "thinkfuture", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/thinkfuture/", "bidAmount": 3500, "content": "$3,500 bid placed by thinkfuture", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736801255, "type": "bat-bid"}, {"id": 16575537, "authorName": "treybiensmith", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/treybiensmith/", "bidAmount": 3600, "content": "$3,600 bid placed by treybiensmith", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736803263, "type": "bat-bid"}, {"id": 16575701, "authorName": "thinkfuture", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/thinkfuture/", "bidAmount": 4100, "content": "$4,100 bid placed by thinkfuture", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736803825, "type": "bat-bid"}, {"id": 16575729, "authorName": "Mouse51", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/mouse51/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "Road was rocky starting out but has smoothed out towards the end \ud83d\udc4c", "likes": 2, "timestamp": 1736803908, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16575833, "authorName": "thinkfuture", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/thinkfuture/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "Sold on 1/13/25 for $4,100 to thinkfuture", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736804280, "type": "bat-bid-reserve"}, {"id": 16575885, "authorName": "FanofClassic_BMW (The Seller)", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/fanofclassic_bmw/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "Congratulations @thinkfuture! I will reach out shortly for shipping arrangements.", "likes": 1, "timestamp": 1736804508, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16576177, "authorName": "thinkfuture", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/thinkfuture/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "@FanofClassicBMW I am available by phone, text or email. Thank you!", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736806847, "type": "comment"}, {"id": 16580750, "authorName": "StaffordRestorations", "authorUrl": "https://bringatrailer.com/member/staffordrestorations/", "bidAmount": 0, "content": "I\u2019m glad this auction did \u201cdecent $\u201d.\r\nThe R50/5 is a great bike and EZ to punch out the 600 without any outward signs.", "likes": 0, "timestamp": 1736878020, "type": "comment"}]